Does Costco Do Graduation Cakes? 5 Easy Steps to Order Yours Now

Graduation season brings so much excitement—and a whole lot of planning! When my niece graduated last spring, I knew we needed a cake that could feed a crowd without breaking the bank. That’s when I remembered Costco’s bakery section. Their sheet cakes are legendary for celebrations, but does Costco do graduation cakes? I’m happy to report—yes! Many locations offer customizable graduation cakes perfect for open houses or smaller gatherings. From personal experience, their cakes are not only budget-friendly but also deliciously moist (that vanilla buttercream is *chef’s kiss*). Whether you’re celebrating high school, college, or even kindergarten milestones, Costco might just have the sweet solution you need.

Table of Contents

Does Costco Do Graduation Cakes?

Yes! Many Costco locations offer graduation cakes, though availability varies by store. I learned this firsthand when I ordered one for my nephew’s party last year. Their classic half-sheet cake (serves about 48) is the most common option, decorated with simple but elegant graduation-themed designs—think caps, diplomas, or even customizable text with the graduate’s name and year. Some locations might have round cakes or additional decorative touches, so it’s always worth asking.

While Costco doesn’t do elaborate fondant designs like specialty bakeries, their buttercream frosting is smooth, and you can often choose between vanilla or chocolate cake (or even marble!). Pro tip: Call your local warehouse a few weeks ahead, especially in May or June—their bakery team can confirm what’s possible, like adding school colors or a simple edible image. Just don’t expect last-minute miracles; these cakes are popular for a reason!

Why Choose a Costco Graduation Cake

Listen, I get it—when you’re planning a graduation party, the cake can feel like one more thing on your endless to-do list. But here’s why Costco cakes are my secret weapon:

• Budget-friendly: At around $20 for a half-sheet cake, you’re getting way more bang for your buck than at most bakeries
• Feeds a crowd: That half-sheet serves 48 people easily—perfect when Great Aunt Martha brings her entire bridge club
• Surprisingly delicious: Their vanilla cake is moist (not that dry grocery-store cake texture), and the buttercream is just sweet enough without being cloying
• Simple but festive: The graduation decorations are cute without being over-the-top—ideal if you’re going for that “classy but not fussy” vibe

The best part? You can focus on decorating the house and prepping the grad’s slideshow while Costco handles the cake. Now that’s what I call a win!

How to Order a Costco Graduation Cake

Planning a graduation party? One of the easiest and most affordable ways to feed a crowd—and make a memorable impression—is with a Costco graduation cake. With their generous size, customizable decorations, and crowd-pleasing flavors, these cakes are a go-to for many families during grad season. I’ve personally ordered them for three different family graduations, and I’m here to share everything you need to know—from checking availability to storing it for peak freshness.

Check Availability at Your Local Costco

Before you get too excited about frosting colors and congratulatory messages, the first step is to contact your local Costco bakery. While most Costco locations offer custom cakes, graduation-themed options can be seasonal, especially in high-demand months like May and June. Some bakeries only take limited orders per day during peak graduation season.

Pro Tip: Call or visit the bakery in person around Monday or Tuesday mornings—that’s usually when they’re less busy and can give you their full attention. This is also a good time to ask about design options, lead time, and whether they offer any upgrades like edible images or special themes.

Know What You Want Before Ordering

Once you confirm that your Costco location does graduation cakes, be prepared with a few key details:

• Cake Size: Costco cakes are typically half-sheet cakes that serve 40–48 people—perfect for large gatherings.
• Flavor Options: Choose from vanilla, chocolate, or marble. They’re all layered with a rich mousse-style filling and topped with buttercream frosting.
• Frosting Color & Decorations: Select your graduate’s school colors or opt for classic gold, black, and white. Costco will often have graduation-themed decoration options like diplomas, caps, or “Class of 2024” accents.
• Custom Text: Bring your message—something like “Congrats, Jamie! Class of 2024” works great. Keep it short and sweet; space is limited.
• Extras: Some locations allow you to add edible images for a small fee. I’ve used this to upload senior photos or a school logo—it’s a fun and personal touch that guests love!

Order Timeline: Costco requires orders to be placed at least 48 hours in advance, but during peak graduation months, it’s smart to order 1 to 2 weeks early to ensure your spot.

Pickup & Storage Tips

You’ll be given a pickup time, usually in the morning for maximum freshness. Be sure to:

Let it sit at room temperature for 30 minutes before serving so the buttercream softens. Cold cake = dull flavor and hard frosting!

Bring a clean, flat surface in your vehicle—the cake box is large and you don’t want it sliding around!

Keep it cool if you’re not serving it right away. The frosting holds up well in the fridge.

Costco Graduation Cake Flavors and Sizes

Okay, let’s talk cake specifics—because nothing’s worse than imagining chocolate and getting vanilla, am I right? Most Costco locations stick to the classic half-sheet cake (about 12×16 inches), which is perfect for feeding a crowd of 40-50 guests (or, let’s be real, 25 hungry teenagers). If you’re lucky, your warehouse might offer round cakes (usually 10 inches) for smaller gatherings. Flavor-wise, you’ll typically choose between:

• Vanilla: Light, fluffy, and pairs perfectly with that signature whipped buttercream
• Chocolate: Rich but not overly sweet—my cousin’s kids demolished this one in minutes
• Marble: The best of both worlds, swirls of vanilla and chocolate for indecisive families (no judgment!)

Note: Some locations might offer seasonal flavors, so it never hurts to ask!

Tips for the Best Costco Graduation Cake Experience

After ordering way too many Costco cakes (for research, obviously), I’ve learned a few tricks to make your graduation cake shine:

• Order early: I once tried ordering three days before a party—big mistake. Two weeks is ideal during May/June madness.
• Bring your own decor: Their designs are simple, so grab some edible glitter or grad-themed toppers for extra pizzazz.
• Serve strategically: Cut slices with a hot knife (dip in warm water) for clean edges—your Instagram will thank you.
• Have a backup plan: One location ran out of vanilla last year, so I picked up cupcakes too. Crisis averted!
• Snag extra plates: Their cake boxes include thin ones, but sturdy disposable plates handle buttercream better.

Remember—it’s about celebrating, not perfection. Even if the frosting smudges, it’ll still taste amazing!

FAQs About Costco Graduation Cakes

Q1. Can I add a photo to my Costco graduation cake?
Some locations offer edible image printing for an extra fee! Call ahead to check—you’ll usually email them a high-res photo. My friend added her son’s senior portrait last year, and it looked fantastic (though simpler designs work best). Just know not all warehouses provide this service.

Q2. How far in advance should I order?
Here’s my golden rule: At least 1 week during non-peak times, but aim for 2 weeks in May/June graduation season. I learned the hard way when my local Costco had a 10-day backlog. Weekday orders often have more flexibility than weekend rush orders.

Q3. What’s the price range for graduation cakes?
The classic half-sheet cake runs about $18-$25 (depending on location), making it a steal compared to specialty bakeries. Round cakes or extra decorations might cost slightly more. Pro tip: Prices don’t usually include tax, so budget accordingly.

Q4. Can I customize the colors and text?
Absolutely! Most locations let you choose frosting colors (great for school pride) and add personalized messages. When my niece graduated, we did gold lettering on navy frosting—simple but elegant. Just keep text brief; their decorators aren’t writing novels!

Q5. Do they offer gluten-free or vegan options?
Unfortunately no—Costco’s graduation cakes contain wheat, eggs, and dairy. For dietary restrictions, check their bakery case for alternative desserts or consider supplementing with a small specialty cake.

Nutritional Information

Just a heads up—Costco doesn’t provide exact nutrition details for their graduation cakes since ingredients can vary slightly by location. But based on their standard sheet cakes, a typical slice (about 1/12 of the cake) runs around 350 calories with 25g sugar. If you’re watching specific dietary needs, definitely ask at your local bakery for their most current info. And hey, it’s a celebration—maybe just enjoy that buttercream guilt-free for one day!

Share Your Graduation Cake Story

Did you grab a Costco cake for your graduate’s big day? I’d love to hear how it turned out! Was the vanilla as dreamy as I remember? Any hilarious last-minute cake emergencies? Drop your stories below—because let’s be real, half the fun is swapping these sweet celebration memories.

Print